Skip to main content

What Great Leaders Do to Advance AI

|

Unpack how the best bosses handle major technological transformation

Parallel digital roads leading towards a target.
iStock/Ilya Lukichev

When Rob Fauber, President and CEO of global financial intelligence powerhouse Moody’s Corporation, likened his firm’s approach to adopting AI as “sprinting into the fog,” he captured a common sentiment.

The rapid and pervasive advancement of AI has a lot of leaders charging forward on a path that isn’t always clear — and not everyone is comfortable with the ambiguity. While most senior leaders are enthusiastic about the technology’s potential, the vast majority are also very aware of its risks. Only 14 per cent of leaders surveyed by global leadership firm DDI’s Global Leadership Forecast 2027 feel prepared to use emerging technologies successfully.

In a recent Smith webinar called AI Does (Not) Matter, Smith School of Business professors Abayomi Baiyere and Kathryn Brohman delved into the varied leadership challenges emerging as the AI era matures, and offered some insights into what effective leadership looks like in a period of transformation as dramatic as the current moment. 

Read on for three takeaways.

Takeaway #1: Great leaders ask “what if?”

Baiyere kicked off the conversation with some important context. “I think we are in a point right now where AI is necessary to compete,” he said. “But it is not sufficient to win.” 

There’s plenty of historical evidence to support Baiyere’s view. When the internet first arrived, few companies gained a competitive edge just by building a website, he explained. When mobile took hold, not many were able to get ahead just by developing an app. Similarly, as AI takes hold in all facets of modern commerce, he’s not counting on companies to come out on top solely by integrating CoPilot, Claude or ChatGPT. “The tool has never once been the transformation,” Baiyere said.

Rather, he pointed out, differentiation comes when leaders have the ability to pair technological capabilities with real vision: “What really matters is your ability to imagine possibilities based on the AI foundation that you have built.” 

In simplest terms, this amounts to a change in mindset: away from tracking what tools the team has access to, and toward how the organization can mobilize people and resources to apply AI in new, novel and beneficial ways.

“For leaders, the questions need to be: What else can we do with AI, beyond what Anthropic, OpenAI and the experts have told us?,” he said. “What are the unique capabilities of your organization that, combined with AI, can open up new ways of seeing and rethinking your organization?”

AI Does (Not) Matter
Webinar Recording AI Does (Not) Matter

Takeaway #2: Great leaders plan for uncertainty

Leading a team through the ascent of AI is to live in a near-constant state of paradox, according to Brohman. “You need to know where you’re going, but at the same time, the answer keeps changing,” she said. “By next week, there could be something new: a new LLM, or a new tool. You have to lead in an environment that really does feel like chaos.”

Brohman acknowledged that this can make for an anxious situation for a lot of leaders. It’s tough for those who have had a rocky time leading through technological transformation before. It’s tough for tech leads who like the certainty of traditional IT projects with fixed terms and sets of variables. And it’s tough for non-technical leaders struggling to get their heads around the complexity of AI. “It’s an unusual challenge,” Brohman said. “You’re expected to provide direction at precisely the moment when many of the assumptions underlying your organizations are becoming less certain.”

That’s why researchers — including Brohman — are exploring new ways of leading through the era of AI. Brohman detailed a concept she calls “stagility,” which integrates stability (which manifests as grounding decisions in as many fixed elements as possible: values, principles, accountability, strategic intent and guardrails) and agility (which creates the latitude to explore changing tools, practices, workflows, roles and methods of experimentation).”

“When you’re managing in the stagility imperative, you do not wait for uncertainty to disappear, because we all know that’s never going to happen,” Brohman said. “AI-capable leadership is not about knowing where AI is going. It’s about being able to lead while the answer keeps changing.”

Takeaway #3: Great leaders support skeptics

For all the buzz about AI in corner offices, many employees  —nearly 50 per cent of Canadian workers by some counts — have real reservations about using AI. Furthermore, in most organizations there’s a notable disconnect between the enthusiasm of bosses and those who report to them. According to a 2026 Deloitte Canada report, 76 per cent of executives feel their teams are keen to use AI, only 31 per cent of those team members agree. 

Both Baiyere and Brohman agreed that AI skepticism presents a real, and growing, challenge for leaders charged with accelerating the technology.

Baiyere recommended an empathetic approach. “People often have very legitimate reasons to be reluctant,” he said, citing fear of losing jobs, wariness to train technology meant to replace humans, and concerns about the environmental impact of data centres. Hesitation to get on board is, in his view, “a very natural reaction.” He recommends leaders start by talking frankly with reluctant employees to diagnose the reason for skepticism. “That helps to start figuring out ‘What is the best way forward here?’” he said. “The way you communicate about AI matters a lot in how people see it. So do the incentives you give people to try it.” 

Brohman advocated for a “soft-touch” approach that gives people avoiding AI a chance to familiarize themselves with the technology. “Sometimes people are resisting because they don’t know how to use AI, or where to start,” she said. “Many of the downsides and dark sides of AI are true. So, it’s about embracing the truth that there is good and bad in this, allowing people to talk about it, and creating a safe space for people to try, explore and find things that might work for them.”

Leading Organizational Transformation in the Age of AI